A Reflection on Matthew 25:31-46 – The Solemnity of Our Lord Jesus Christ, King of the Universe
As we come to the conclusion of the Church’s liturgical year, Matthew presents us with one of the most challenging passages in his Gospel. Jesus speaks of the Son of Man coming in glory, accompanied by the angels, to sit upon his throne and gather all the nations before him. It is an extraordinary image of kingship and judgement, yet the criteria by which people are judged are perhaps not what we would ordinarily associate with a king exercising supreme authority.
There is no examination of wealth, influence or social standing. Instead, the King speaks about those who were hungry, thirsty, strangers, without clothing, sick or imprisoned. The decisive question concerns how people responded to those whose circumstances made them especially vulnerable.
I find this an appropriate, although demanding, way to conclude our journey through Matthew’s Gospel. Throughout the year we have listened to Jesus teaching his disciples what it means to belong to the Kingdom of Heaven. Now, in the final teaching before the account of his Passion, we are confronted with the consequences of accepting, or failing to accept, that invitation.
The Shepherd Who Comes to Judge
The placement of this passage is significant. It brings to a conclusion the final great discourse of Jesus in Matthew’s Gospel, which has concerned the future of Jerusalem, the circumstances in which disciples must live while awaiting the Lord’s coming, and the final fulfilment of God’s purposes.
The imagery also draws upon the Old Testament, particularly the prophetic tradition in which God appears as the shepherd of his people. In Ezekiel, God condemns shepherds who have neglected their responsibilities and declares that he himself will seek out and care for his sheep. There is also an element of judgement, as God distinguishes between members of the flock according to how they have treated one another.
Matthew brings these themes together in the figure of the Son of Man. The one who comes in glory is also the shepherd who knows his flock and the King whose authority reveals the true character of God’s Kingdom.
There is an important contrast here. We might expect a description of Christ’s kingship to emphasise majesty, power and dominion. Matthew certainly does not deny his glory, but he directs our attention towards something quite different. The King identifies himself with those who have the least power and whose needs are most easily overlooked.
This tells us something fundamental about the Kingdom that Jesus has come to establish.
Who Are the Least of These?
One question that arises from this Gospel concerns the identity of those whom Jesus calls the least of his brothers and sisters. Some passages elsewhere in Matthew suggest that the expression may refer particularly to the disciples who have been sent out to proclaim the Gospel. Earlier, Jesus speaks about receiving his messengers and promises that even someone who gives a cup of cold water to one of these little ones will not lose their reward.
On that understanding, the passage would concern the reception given to those who carry Christ’s message, particularly when they experience hardship or persecution.
There is, however, a broader interpretation which I find particularly compelling. Throughout Matthew’s Gospel, and especially in the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus calls his disciples to a generosity that reaches beyond familiar relationships and established obligations. We are commanded to love our enemies, to respond mercifully and to recognise the demands of righteousness in our dealings with others.
Within that wider teaching, the hungry, the stranger, the sick and the imprisoned can be understood as representing all those whose circumstances place them in need of our compassion.
I do not think we can dismiss the question of interpretation entirely, but I am inclined towards this broader application. Certainly, we cannot use the uncertainty about precisely whom Jesus intended to restrict our responsibility towards those who suffer.
What matters is the extraordinary identification Jesus makes between himself and those who are vulnerable. He does not simply say that caring for them is something he approves of. He tells us that what we do for them, we do for him.
The implications of that statement deserve our serious attention.
The Good We Have Failed to Do
When I listened to the Gospel again, I was particularly struck by the reasons given for the judgement. Those on the King’s left are not accused of committing some dramatic act of wrongdoing. Their failure consists principally in what they did not do.
They did not feed the hungry, welcome the stranger, clothe those in need or visit the sick and imprisoned. Opportunities for mercy were present, but they remained unanswered.
I think this is an aspect of Christian responsibility that we can easily overlook. When we examine our consciences, we often concentrate upon the things we have done wrong: occasions when we have acted selfishly, spoken unkindly, failed to tell the truth or neglected a particular obligation. These are certainly important matters, but the Gospel asks us to consider something further.
What about the good that was within our capacity to do but which we neglected? What about the person whose loneliness we noticed but did nothing to relieve, the neighbour experiencing difficulties whom we never contacted, or the stranger whose circumstances called for some practical expression of welcome?
Such omissions may not always arise from deliberate indifference. Frequently, we become so occupied with our own concerns that we fail to recognise what is happening around us. The demands of ordinary life can narrow our attention until the needs of others scarcely register.
Yet the Gospel reminds us that our responsibility as disciples includes the willingness to look beyond ourselves and recognise those who may otherwise remain unseen.
This is particularly challenging because there is no obvious limit suggested to our attentiveness. We cannot respond personally to every need in the world, but neither can we allow that impossibility to become an excuse for overlooking those whom we genuinely have the opportunity to help.
Looking with the Eyes of Faith
There is another striking feature of Matthew’s account. Both groups express surprise at the King’s judgement. Those who acted mercifully did not realise that they were serving Christ, while those who failed to respond insist that they never knowingly neglected him.
Their common question is essentially the same: when did we see you?
I think this brings us to the importance of learning to see with the eyes of faith. Jesus is not physically recognisable in every suffering person in the ordinary sense, yet he tells us that our treatment of such people has a direct relationship to our treatment of him.
Christian discipleship therefore asks us to develop a different way of recognising the presence of Christ. We encounter him in the Scriptures, in prayer and in the sacramental life of the Church, but we must also learn to recognise his claim upon us through the needs of the people around us.
The love of neighbour that Jesus commands is more demanding than simply being pleasant towards those with whom we live and work. It requires us to become attentive to people whose suffering may be quiet, whose circumstances are difficult, or whose needs do not naturally attract our attention.
In a society where loneliness, poverty, illness and social isolation remain significant realities, this teaching has lost none of its urgency.
Accountability at the End of the Journey
The final words of the passage are confronting because they speak of eternal punishment and eternal life. There is a definitive quality to the judgement, much like the closed door in the earlier parable of the bridesmaids.
Across these final chapters of Matthew, we have repeatedly encountered the themes of readiness and accountability. The bridesmaids are asked to prepare for the bridegroom’s coming. The servants entrusted with talents must account for the way they have used what they received. Now the nations are gathered before the Son of Man, and the reality of their response to others is brought into the light.
These teachings remind us that discipleship is not simply a matter of professing our faith. It must become visible in the way we live.
I do not understand this to mean that we earn salvation through a collection of good deeds. Salvation remains the gift of God’s grace. But the grace we receive is intended to transform us, enabling us to participate in the love and mercy that characterise the Kingdom.
Our response to the vulnerable is therefore not something separate from our relationship with Christ. It is one of the ways in which that relationship becomes authentic.
Encountering Christ in the Year Ahead
As I reflect upon this Gospel at the end of the liturgical year, I find myself invited to a broader examination of conscience. How has my relationship with Christ developed during the year? Have I become more attentive to his presence, more generous in my response to others and more willing to recognise needs that I might previously have overlooked?
I am particularly conscious of the need to examine not only what I have done, but what I might still be called to do.
Lectio Divina invites us to move from hearing the Scriptures towards responding to the Lord who speaks through them. For me, that response begins with a renewed willingness to look around me, particularly towards those whose needs may be easily missed.
The Feast of Christ the King reminds us that the reign of Christ is not established through worldly domination. It is revealed through the love of the one who gives himself completely for the life of the world, and who calls his disciples to share that same self-giving love.
Next week, a new liturgical year begins, and once again we commence our journey with Christ. There is something encouraging in that rhythm of returning to the Scriptures, listening again and discovering new opportunities for conversion.
We have not yet become everything Christ calls us to be, but we are continually invited to respond more faithfully.
Perhaps the most important question with which to conclude this year is whether, when Christ comes to us in the person who is hungry, lonely, sick, imprisoned or simply forgotten, we will have learned to recognise him.
For the King whom we proclaim in glory is also the Lord who waits to be encountered in the lives of those most in need of our love.
Bishop David Walker